M, Bali earthquake and multiculturalism

I can’t resist quoting M’s latest Facebook travel update:

Had almost 40km bicycle ride today to immigration office in Denpasar, it was interesting ride on Bali chaotic road but I feel very safe as all the drivers not aggressive and very patient and calm! Having a couple of Guinness at Kuta beach and watching sunset, actually there was a little earthquake at this morning in Bali, whole hotel was shaking I thought it was someone having sex, I was saying “ what is going on please stop it”

Also on Facebook another friend has sounded a challenging note about multiculturalism. He is referring to an opinion piece in Monday’s Herald.

Dr Justin Koonin is in a bubble and so are all advocates of multiculturalism – a political accommodation for demographic reality but like most governmental sleight of hand, unsustainable and hypocritical. Unsustainable because in a few decades our people will carry the genes from four continents and they will follow a culture that is yet to be experienced. They will not practice one or all of their grandparents customs for they will be imbued with the contemporary Anglo culture. Moreover, a culture incorporates laws governing the conduct and relations of its communities. British law reigns in all Anglo Saxon lands. There is little accommodation for any other legal code. Furthermore, the connection between Hitler and religious freedom is somewhat thin. .

Rather than picking through all that I refer you to some older posts of mine. Not all the internal links in those posts will work, though quite a few still do. That’s one of the downsides of hypertexting meeting time and net decay, but for what they are worth here goes:

personal identity

First: Malouf and Maalouf: reading July 2005. Then: 2007 — Religion: Who Needs It? — The Heathlander.

It is all very hypothetical though. Religion isn’t about to go away, not in my lifetime or probably in yours. Me, I am a believer in God who does not believe in magic books. So I agree entirely about the dubious morality of much of the Bible, but not of all of the Bible, and ditto for the Quran, though here is an interesting conundrum for the world as Muslims tend to be wedded to the magic book principle even more than Christians or Jews. Rather than go into all that here, I refer you to entries on my archive page under the tag “Bible”.

So I do not identify with this characterisation of religion:

…Rather than a rational discussion of morality culminating in a series of arguments, religious morality is just a set of rules written down on paper, with no attempt at rational explanation and no critical discussion of the issues. Moreover, believers are positively discouraged from thinking for themselves about morality, and are rather indoctrinated or terrified into blindly following whatever their “Holy Book” or “religious teacher” has to say. That’s not morality, it’s tyrannical brainwashing…

Rather, I do lean towards this comment in Meanjin Vol. 65, no. 4, 2006:

Modern-day Christians have to stop thinking that they do not need to engage in dialogue because they have found their good shepherd. Having to engage with those of a different faith is not always comfortable. But in our post-secular society, in which the boundary between belief and unbelief is much less clear than for previous generations, interfaith dialogue is the way of the future…

We are becoming a society in whch secular and religious cultures coexist, and indeed can sometimes learn from each other. In that sense we may be moving to a post-secular generation.

— Constant J Mews, Monash University

Next Is Australia a Christian country? — also from 2007.  Finally, from 2011: Being Australian 11: inclusive multiculturalism Aussie style 4.


Australian media owners and journalists unite to call for laws to protect a free press

Thanks AdNews.

Media owners have united in an open letter to Prime Minister Scott Morrison asking him to defend press freedom in Australia.

The “Journalism is not a Crime” letter was published in News Corp Australia newspapers, including The Australian, and Nine newspapers, including The Sydney Morning Herald.

The letter, also signed by some of the nation’s most prominent journalists, including Karen Middleton, David Marr, Kathrine Murphy, Laurie Oaks and Malcolm Farr, calls for legislation to “recognise and enshrine a positive public interest protection for whistleblowers and for journalists”….


Morrison’s unfortunate choice

I shuddered:

The man responsible for community safety and multiculturalism in Scott Morrison’s new ministry has pledged to work closely with Islamic, Sudanese and other key communities but is making no apology for leading the charge against “African gangs” in his home city.

Liberal MP Jason Wood, a supporter of Peter Dutton in last year’s leadership coup, will now work underneath Mr Dutton in the Home Affairs portfolio as assistant minister for customs, community safety and multicultural affairs….

Not a good omen at all!

I have been beavering away over the years on this and previous blogs. Here is one set I am still very proud of and committed to:

Being Australian

In January 2011 I posted a series exploring this topic. Creating this page has also revealed I misnumbered the posts! Now corrected.


  1. Being Australian 1 — Waleed Aly on SBS last night

  2. Being Australian 2: the search for a lost utopia

  3. Being Australian 3: Richard Tognetti, Wollongong, multiculturalism

  4. Being Australian 4: joined the Diggers Club, mate!

And more. Do look!

Sorry Bob! Well, there you go…

Today I am carrying a souvenir from my time in Surry Hills. Strangely relevant again!  And no, I am not foaming at the mouth — that’s morning coffee from Diggers.


Oh — and at least the Bunnies won, unlike Scomo’s Sharks!


I am determined today not to get hysterical about the Australian election result. Rather, let me itemise some good things.

First, remember that ratbag Fraser Anning visiting Cronulla not long ago, and how it ended with a cameraman losing his shirt? You will be pleased to know that the people of Cook are not all bad: FA’s candidate got 0.6% of the vote!

Second, Gilmore rejected Scomo’s drop-in candidate! Labor won with 52.8% of the vote, after preferences.

Third, that gross creature Clive Palmer failed to win any seats at all, either in the Reps or the Senate! Unfortunately, his preferences and his toxic ads were a factor, especially no doubt in Queensland.

And speaking of Queensland, despite the best efforts of my relatives up there, it was likely the key place of Labor destruction, in no small part because of the Adani mine issue. My two cents worth: I do wish Bob Brown hadn’t taken his Sunday School Picnic to the Carmichael Valley. It no doubt had the reverse effect to that intended.

So there we go, folks! My footy tipping (Bunnies excepted) was pretty ratshit this week too — but we live to fight another day.

Seriously though, at my age there is every possibility I won’t live to see another Labor government. In three years I will be older than my father was when he passed away!

Legend! Bob Hawke 1929-2019

Here I am holding one of Bob Hawke’s enduring legacies.


And here is his last legacy, just last week:


Labor elder Bob Hawke has written an open letter to voters calling on them to vote for Bill Shorten and his team at Saturday’s federal election.

“While Bill’s political opponents argue his trade union background is a liability for a future prime minister, I consider it an asset, as it was for me,” the former Labor prime minister writes.